How our brains control our arms
Recording the neural activity of monkeys as they plan to reach, or just react, will help engineers design better brain controlled prosthetic limbs
Ready, set, go.
Sometimes that's how our brains work. When we anticipate a physical act, such as reaching for the keys we noticed on the table, the neurons that control the task adopt a state of readiness, like sprinters bent into a crouch.
Other times, however, our neurons must simply react, such as if someone were to toss us the keys without gesturing first, to prepare us to catch.
How do the neurons in the brain control planned versus unplanned arm movements?
Krishna Shenoy, a Stanford professor of electrical engineering, neurobiology (by courtesy) and bioengineering (affiliate), wanted to answer that question as part of his group's ongoing efforts to develop and improve brain-controlled prosthetic devices.
In a paper published in the journal Neuron, Shenoy and first author Katherine Cora Ames, a doctoral student in the Neurosciences Graduate Program, present a mathematical analysis of the brain activity of monkeys as they make anticipated and unanticipated reaching motions.
Monitoring the neurons
The experimental data came from recording the electrical activity of neurons in the brain that control motor and premotor functions. The idea was to observe and understand the activity levels of these neurons during experiments in which the monkeys made planned or reactive arm movements.
What the researchers found is that when the monkeys knew what arm movement they were supposed to make and were simply waiting for the cue to act, electrical readings showed that the neurons went into what scientists call the prepare-and-hold state -- the brain's equivalent of ready, set waiting for the cue to go.
But when the monkeys made unplanned or unexpected movements, the neurons did not go through the expected prepare-and-hold state.
"This was a surprise," Ames said.
Before the experiment, the researchers had believed that a prepare-and-hold state had to precede movement. In short, they thought the neurons had to go into a "ready, set" crouch before acting on the "go" command.
But they discovered otherwise in three variations of an experiment involving similar arm movements.
In all three cases the monkeys were trained to touch a target that appeared on a display screen.
During each motion, the researchers measured the electrical activity of the neurons in control of arm movements.
In one set of experiments, the monkeys were shown the target but were trained not to touch it until they got the "go" signal. This is called a delayed reach experiment. It served as the planned action.
In a second set of experiments the monkeys were trained to touch the target as soon as it appeared. This served as the unplanned action.
In a third variant, the position of the target was changed. It briefly appeared in one location on the screen. The target then reappeared in a different location. This required the monkeys to revise their movement plan.
First monkey see, then monkey do
Ames said that, in all three instances, the first information to reach the neurons was awareness of the target. "Perception always occurred first," Ames said.
Then, about 50 milliseconds later, some differences appeared in the data.
When the monkeys had to wait for the go command, the brain recordings showed that the neurons went into a discernable prepare-and-hold state.
But in the other two cases, the neurons did not enter the prepare-and-hold state.
Instead, roughly 50 milliseconds after the electrical readings showed evidence of perception, a change in neuronal activity signaled the command to touch the target; it came with no apparent further preparation between perception and action. "Ready, set" was unnecessary. In these instances, the neurons just said, "Go!"
"This study changes our view of how movement is controlled," Ames said. "First you get the information about where to move. Then comes the decision to move. There is no specific prepare-and-hold stage unless you are waiting for the signal to move."
These nuanced understandings are important to Shenoy. His lab develops and improves electronic systems that can convert neural activity into electronic signals in order to control a prosthetic arm or move the cursor on a computer screen.
One example of such efforts is the BrainGate clinical trial here at Stanford, now being conducted under U.S. Food & Drug Administration supervision, to test the safety of brain-controlled, computer cursor systems – "think-and-click" communication for people who can't move.
"In addition to advancing basic brain science, these new findings will lead to better brain-controlled prosthetic arms and communication systems for people with paralysis," Shenoy said.
Other news from the department science
New approach to testing for long Covid
Blood vessels in the eye altered with persistent coronavirus symptoms
Pixel-by-pixel analysis yields insights into lithium-ion batteries
In a first, researchers have observed how lithium ions flow through a battery interface, which could help optimize the material’s design
Researchers create pioneering approaches for the detection of viral antigens
Sybodies: a revolution in biological recognition
‘Lab-on-a-drone’ sends science skyward to keep track of smelly air pollution
A low-cost 3D printed analytical IoT platform for vertical monitoring of gaseous hydrogen sulphide
Observing nanoparticles with unprecedented precision
Illuminated: Researchers investigate new physical phenomena on the nanoscale with microstructured fibers
Start-up recycles plastic lab waste into new test tubes and petri dishes
University of Bath is home to UK’s first pilot plant for recycling plastic lab waste
Gotcha! New technology speeds up bacterial testing in food
A promising technology that could potentially revolutionize the process of testing bacterial viability in food
Benchtop NMR spectroscopy can accurately analyse pyrolysis oils
More accessible analysis could help develop the potential of bio-oils as an alternative to fossil fuels
Structure formation during freeze casting filmed in 3D and real time
Freeze-cast materials can be used for many applications: as battery electrodes, catalyst materials or in biomedicine
Virtual lab calculates optimal lubricant composition
Extending lubricant lifespan: Sensor system developed for real-time monitoring
Unpacking the smart way
How Incoming adenoviruses change their chromatin structure for efficient gene expression
New "radar" detects active cellular destroyers
Study provide an unprecedented look at the actors involved in the dynamic changes of our protein balance
Fondant under the magnifying glass
New insights into the properties of sweet coating: The results could be used to optimize the industrial production process in the future
Most read news
Benchtop NMR spectroscopy can accurately analyse pyrolysis oils
Scientists use quantum device to slow down simulated chemical reaction 100 billion times
What happens in femtoseconds in nature can now be observed in milliseconds in the lab
Fondant under the magnifying glass
KNAUER invests in Dresden-based start-up company
Both companies will offer integrated solutions in the field of material separation and laboratory organisation
More news from our other portals
Major breakthrough in the development of electric vehicle batteries
New study finds ways to suppress lithium plating in automotive batteries for faster charging electric vehicles
Cells with an ear for music release insulin
For the first time, researchers are using music, including Queen's global hit "We will rock you," to stimulate insulin release from cells
Clean water from fog
A property known as photocatalytic memory ensures that this also functions when skies are overcast and at night
Research shows table salt could be the secret ingredient for better chemical recycling
Table salt as the key to the plastics recycling revolution?
Microbe of the Year 2023: Bacillus subtilis – for health and technology
Already, Bacillus subtilis is indispensable in many industries, and many more innovations are expected
Green, sweet and crisp - New apple variety Pia41 approved
The apple bred at the Julius Kühn Institute receives variety protection
Leipzig-based start-up converts CO₂ into green chemicals with patented plasma catalysis
CO₂ recycling as a useful complement to carbon capture and storage
Younger generation gets sick earlier and more often than older generation
In spite of their advanced age, they are in the middle of life, healthy, active and mentally alert – they are referred to as the “young old”
Sugar: Small increase in production despite record prices
EU sugar market more than in need of reform to keep medium-sized processing companies competitive
New battery holds promise for green energy
Redox-flow battery eliminates costly and inefficient membrane
How sleep deprivation can harm the brain
Sleep deprivation decreases the amount of a factor that protects neurons
A Second Life for Electric Car Batteries
Scientists develop a decision model for retired lithium-ion batteries
A microchip for Parmigiano Reggiano cheese
Consorzio del Parmigiano Reggiano, p-Chip Corporation, and Kaasmerk Matec Partner to Launch Breakthrough in Food-Safe Digital Tracking Technology
World record: World's longest-range electric car comes from Munich
Electric car drives over 2500 kilometres on a single battery charge
A whole new order of bacteria could hold the key to improving biogas production
The discovery was made by researchers from Germany, Spain and the Netherlands
Green methanol for shipping and industry: € 10.4 Mio. for the "Leuna100" project
A consortium of two Fraunhofer institutes, DBI-Gastechnologisches Institut Freiberg, Technical University of Berlin and C1 makes industrial history at the Leuna site
How to inactivate common cold viruses
In the cold season, cold viruses are everywhere. But we can do something about it
Straws and disposable tableware: Also made of paper often with harmful chemicals for the environment and health
The supposedly better alternative is often not better at all, scientists emphasize
How minimal genetic differences can turn healthy food into a deadly danger
You are what you eat - this old saying could take on a new dimension according to latest research results
At which age we are at our happiest
An evaluation of over 400 samples shows how subjective well-being develops over the course of a lifespan
Making plant-based meat more ‘meaty’ — with fermented onions
When fermented with specific type of fungus, normally pungent onions can produce the same sort of chemicals that make meats smell ‘meaty’
New lithium battery with simple production and high safety developed
"This study underscores the importance of molecular structure design in creating effective additives for quasi-solid-state electrolytes"
New compound unleashes the immune system on metastases
A new nanocomplex renders a tumor harmless – and, on top of that, it trains the immune system to detect and eliminate metastases